Heeding The Mistakes Of Others
In a group setting, one has the ability to watch others make mistakes and learn from them. For example, in a substance abuse group, one member may go to a club thinking drugs would not be available–and therefore not present a temptation–and find out they were wrong. When that member shares the information with the group, it can keep another member from going to the same club.
Ethnic And Cultural Matching
Although arguments for matching the ethnicity of the therapist with that of the group members treated may have some merit, the reality is that such a course seldom is feasible. Health care providers from culturally and linguistically diverse groups are underrepresented in the current service delivery system, so it is likely that a group leader will be from the mainstream culture . While it might be ideal to match all participants by ethnicity in a therapeutic group, the most important determinants of success are the values and attitudes shared by the therapist and group members .
It should be noted that recent research suggests that an ethnic match between therapist and client does not consistently improve outcomes . Other research suggests that, while the ethnicity of the therapist is a factor that can influence treatment, it is by no means the most important factor. Culturally specific homogeneous groups should be used only when someone’s cultural, religious, or political beliefs are very different from the mainstream and they are not open to adjustments, as, for example, with recent immigrants or refugees .
If less acculturated people with limited language skills are treated in groups, the program should provide bilingual clinicians who are sensitive to gender and culture. Therapists should focus on problem-oriented, short-term treatment should consider employing a proactive therapeutic style and should be aware that clients may view them as authority figures .
The Disadvantages Of Utilizing Group Therapy
1. There can be personality conflicts. In a 1-on-1 therapy session, a personality conflict between a therapist and patient can be easily controlled. In a group therapy sessions, every additional member of the group increases the risk of a conflict occurring. These personality conflicts can hold people back from the coping mechanisms they need to work on and could even lead to additional concerns.
2. It can make people uncomfortable. Many group therapy sessions involve personal discussions that can become very intense. Some therapists may use role-playing scenarios or encourage group members to share very graphic details of the issue at-hand. That kind of setup can make anyone squirm, but the level of discomfort can peak to a point for some where there is no therapeutic value to being in the group.
3. Not every person is a good candidate for group therapy. An individual must be able to function on their own, completing daily living activities successfully, for group therapy to be a potential success. Individuals who find themselves in a crisis situation or are struggling with suicidal thoughts or tendencies are not good candidates for group therapy. Higher levels of crisis create lower-level results with this type of therapy.
Would you like to share some of your personal experiences with group therapy? How do you think it may have helped you?
Read Also: Nc Board Of Physical Therapy
Youtube Video: Leading Therapy Groups With Adolescents
If youâre curious to see an actual group therapy session unfold, this video can satisfy that curiosity! In the video, two group therapists facilitate a group therapy session with teenagers.
You will get an idea of the atmosphere of a group therapy session with adolescents and a model of effective facilitation from the two therapists. In the video description, there is a link to the full video if youâre hungry for more.
Types Of Therapy Groups
The general tone and direction of the group therapy session will vary depending on the type of group. There are many different kinds of groups with different areas of focus, but they generally fall into one of two categories:
1) Psychoeducational â These groups are intended to provide members with the information they need to address or cope with whatever it is that brought them to the group they are usually structured with specific topics or modules to cover.
2) Process-Oriented â These groups are more focused on experience, sharing with one another, and making connections discussion among the members dominates this group rather than a set agenda .
Groups can be further broken down by discussion topics and the structure of the group itself. Some of the most common therapy groups include:
Recommended Reading: Physical Therapy Great Falls Mt
What Is Group Therapy Definitions And Theories
At the most basic level, group therapy is:
âa form of psychotherapy that involves one or more therapists working with several people at the same time .â
It is usually a complement to individual therapy and sometimes medication as well, although it may be used as a stand-alone treatment for certain issues or problems.
According to one of the most renowned group therapists, Dr. Irvin D. Yalom, there are 11 key principles of group therapy:
Professionals Advice On Group Therapy
If you are considering this therapy, it is important to speak with a professional who can provide more information about:
- the different types of groups available, and
- the suitable options for you
They can also help you find a group that is in your area.
NOTE: Professional organizations such as the American Psychological Association and the National Association of Social Workers have ethical guidelines for group therapy. These guidelines outline the expectations that professionals have for themselves and their clients. They also provide a framework for resolving conflicts that may arise during treatment.
Recommended Reading: Laser Therapy For Plantar Fasciitis
What Do I Do If Group Therapy Doesn’t Work
If you’ve tried Group Therapy and it hasn’t worked for you, examine the reasons. Have you not fully-engaged with the process therapy is an interactive process that requires your participation and commitment. If you can’t fully engage, consider why: do you find it hard to be in that kind of group setting, is the way the therapist works right for you?
Not every therapist works the same way, either in individual or Group Therapy. If you don’t have a problem sharing insights with the group, the problem may be that the way your therapist chooses to work just isn’t right for you. If that’s the case, it’s advisable to seek another therapist who runs group sessions in your area.
If you find, however, that you simply don’t enjoy Group Therapy, that you find it hard to be vulnerable in front of strangers, or if you feel you’re not experiencing any benefit, it might be time to find a therapist who will see you on a one-to-one basis. Although the Group Therapy model of sharing pain and insights works for many people, it might not work for you.
What Does Group Therapy Help With
One of the goals of psychotherapy is to learn more about yourself and how your emotions impact your life and relationships. Group therapy provides an environment for you to learn more about yourself while interacting with other people who are experiencing something similar. Having a mental health condition or emotional challenges can be isolating. Group therapy helps you to see that you are not alone in your struggle.
Group therapy provides additional support and accountability. If you keep an open mind, you will likely learn new coping skills as you listen to other people’s experiences with your particular challenges.
Also Check: Idaho Spine And Sports Physical Therapy
Types Of Group Therapy
- Skills Development Groups
These groups focus on strengthening the behavioral and cognitive resources of the members to help them avoid harmful situations and make positive choices. The therapists introduce and improve the skills needed by the members to cope with mental health issues.
Members are helped to cope with life changes which are significant in this group setting. The patients encourage each other to give and receive unconditional acceptance.
- Psycho-Educational Groups
Conditions like substance abuse, phobias, or anxiety are addressed in psycho-educational groups. The group is educated on these conditions and provided with practical coping skills.
- Cognitive Behavioral Groups
The members beliefs that lead to negative behavior are restructured by identifying situations and environments that trigger this behavior.
- Interpersonal Groups
These focus on how interpersonal relationships and social interactions impact your mental health. The psychodynamic approach is used to promote positive change in the patients.
The Principles Of Group Therapy
Group therapy is a popular resource for individuals who have had difficult experiences and who are trying to cope and learn from the past to help shape a better future. Every group therapy session, regardless of its focus, is guided by the same core principles.
These primary principles include:
development or redevelopment of ideal social techniques, and catharsis.
The idea behind a group therapy session is that an individual may be able to find better connection and understanding with another person who has had similar experiences than with a family member, a friend, or even a counselor. It is often helpful for individuals in the early stages of coping with a particular problem, whether it be grief, an illness, or even addiction, to meet another person who has endured similar circumstances but who has experienced personal growth and therapeutic success.
This is where the principles of group therapy come into play. Seeing another person who has lived through the same problem but is better off after experiencing personal growth can encourage hope. Connecting with others who have had similar life experiences presents the opportunity for interpersonal learning and the introduction of practical, proven coping strategies.
Finally, group therapy offers individuals the opportunity to share their stories with those who can understand, and this enables a type of catharsis that talking to a family member or a counselor may not provide.
You May Like: Physical Therapy For Trigger Thumb
The Corrective Recapitulation Of The Primary Family Group
The Theory and Practice of Group Psychotherapy states that therapy groups often resemble family groups, with one or two parental authority figures and some peer siblings.
Within group therapy sessions, people can confront their early childhood experiences and dynamics with these parents and siblings.
They can learn how these early experiences shaped their personality and identify which behaviors and beliefs are unhelpful or destructive in their lives.
What Are The Limitations Of Group Therapy
Group therapy is not a replacement for individual therapy. It is important to remember that this therapy is only as good as the participants make it. Some participants may be uncomfortable revealing personal information in front of other people, while others may struggle to connect with the group members. It can also be difficult to participate if you are dealing with a mental health condition that affects your ability to communicate or concentrate on topics of discussion.
NOTE: If you do not have an interest in it or do not get anything out of this therapy, it may be best to discontinue attendance.
You May Like: Is Physiotherapy The Same As Physical Therapy
Group Therapy Can Be An Effective Treatment For People
Group therapy is a type of therapy that involves therapist working with several people at a time, often 6 to 12 people who experience similar problems. Unlike individual therapy group therapy offers people the opportunity to socialise with others within a supportive and safe environment.
Group therapy can often be used alongside individual therapy and medications. It can show people that they are not alone in their situations and can give them the opportunity to meet others and socialise, which in some cases may be something that is lacking within their lives.
Group therapy can be carried out within community centers, private practices or mental health clinics.
Disadvantages Of Group Therapy
The disadvantages individuals may experience in group therapy include:17
- Not being the center of attention. In many groups, the old adage the squeaky wheel gets the grease seems to apply. Thus, the level of intervention is not as focused and intense for any single person as individual therapy.
- Less confidentiality. Although group members are generally instructed that the information and events that occur in the group are to be held confidential and only to be shared with group members during therapy, the potential for a breach of confidentiality is greater.
- The potential for social loafing. Some individuals in groups do not actually make changes but simply ride on the success of others. Groups may allow unmotivated individuals to hide their issues and avoid accountability.
- A less focused therapeutic alliance.
- Less flexibility. Groups typically meet at specific times. There is less opportunity to fit the therapy into ones personal schedule.
- Not the right fit. Group therapy may be inappropriate for certain types of individuals, such as individuals who are extremely antisocial, extremely shy, impulsive, and passive-aggressive.
Read Also: Occupational Therapy Schools In Chicago
Group Therapy And Substance Abuse Treatment
We are social creatures, and as social creatures, our need to congregate can be a powerful therapeutic tool. Formal therapy groups can be persuasive and supportive. Groups organized around substance misuse can offer individuals insight, guidance, and comfort. Under a therapists guidance, groups can foster healthy attachments as well as teach individuals new social skills. While group therapy is as effective in the treatment of substance misuse as individual therapy, there is mounting evidence that suggests that group therapy might be even more beneficial.14
Individuals who engage in group therapy tend to be more committed to maintaining abstinence.14 Research suggests that group therapy can help with co-occurring mental health disorders, such as depression, anxiety, and personality disorder, too.14
A Brief History Of Group Therapy
According to the American Mental Health Foundation, the first official group therapy session took place in Boston in 1906. Dr. J.H. Pratt provided group instruction about home care to tuberculosis patients who could not afford institutional help. He noticed the beneficial emotional side effects that the group instruction had for his patients.
Between 1906 and 1956 psychotherapy came of age and doctors all around the world were treating patients in a group setting. But it wasnt until the Second World War that group therapy became a widely accepted form of treatment especially for war veterans. In 1944 the U.S. Army issued a training bulletin that noted patients responded well to treatment in groups, and recommended the widespread adoption of the group method.
Today, group therapy has become a well-known practice and is used to treat a variety of mental health issues: addiction, substance abuse, depression, eating disorders, bipolar disorder, and much more. Studies have been showing that group therapy, when properly applied, can be just as effective as individual therapy.
You May Like: How To Do Cupping Therapy
What Are The Advantages And Disadvantages Of Group Therapy
The idea behind group therapy is pretty simple: its therapy with a group of people who share similar issues and experiences.
A more detailed definition comes from the American Psychological Association and defines group therapy as involving one or more psychologists who lead a group of roughly five to 15 patientsMany groups are designed to target a specific problem, such as depression, obesity, panic disorder, social anxiety, chronic pain, or substance abuse. Other groups focus more generally on improving social skills, or helping people deal with a range of issues such as anger, shyness, loneliness, and low self esteem.
Yes, the concept might be simple, but theres a lot more to group therapy than a bunch of people sitting around and talking. Good group therapy is lead by specially trained and certified therapists who have experience in helping people make significant changes within a group setting.
If youre here, youve probably been considering whether or not group therapy is right for you and whether or not it will help you feel better. In fact, you might even be weighing group therapy against individual therapy.
But before we get to the advantages and disadvantages of group therapy, and how it differs from individual therapy, first lets take a look at what exactly group therapy is and how it got started.
The Downsides To Participating In Child Therapy Groups
Treatment in group settings doesnt work for all kids and teens. In some situations, the risk of harm to an individual and to all group members is greater than the potential benefits. For example, youth in crisis or who are suicidal should be counseled individually rather than in a group setting. Children or adolescents with extreme social anxiety would only have that anxiety exacerbated if they had to participate in group counseling.
Other disadvantages to group counseling for youth include:
- Personality clashes that detract from the forward movement of the whole group
- Unwanted and unkind comments from group members to each other
- Frustrations caused by participants interrupting each other or not taking activities seriously
- Trust/mistrust problems can make group members afraid to speak honestly
- Potential breaks in confidentiality
Child therapy groups can be positive, helpful experiences for a lot of kids and teens. Despite the benefits, counseling groups have risks. Its important to carefully consider potential downsides before enrolling your child or teen in a group therapy program.
Don’t Miss: What Is The Success Rate Of Proton Therapy